Skip to product information
1 of 17

Murder at Sugar & Spice Bakery: A Small-Town 24-Letter Cozy Mystery

Murder at Sugar & Spice Bakery: A Small-Town 24-Letter Cozy Mystery

Regular price $123.99 USD
Regular price $168.99 USD Sale price $123.99 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Secrets are rising in Huckleberry Hollow-can Lydia Bellweather crack the case before the dough settles?

💌 The story unfolds over 24 letters

📬 Letters mailed twice per month or binge read with the All-in-one Story Box!

💰 Pay month-to-month, or save by prepaying for the full year 

🧩 Interactive elements with each letter

Want to binge read or slow burn?
View full details

A snail mail cozy mystery delivered 2 times per month over 12 months

I thought Huckleberry Hollow was the safest, coziest place on earth — until I stumbled over a body in the back of my best friend’s bakery.

I’m Lydia Bellweather, journalist, amateur sleuth, and now, the unlikely town investigator in a case I never saw coming.

One minute, I was popping into Sugar & Spice for a cinnamon roll and some gossip with Molly, and the next, we found Rick Jamison — the town’s most disagreeable man — dead as a doornail in her storage room.

The police say it’s an accident, but something about it doesn’t sit right with me.

Maybe it’s the cryptic note I found tucked behind a sack of flour, or the way Rick always seemed to be stirring up trouble with everyone he met.

Either way, Detective Harris won’t take me seriously, and I’m not about to sit by and let this case get swept under the rug.

Armed with my trusty notebook, a few unexpected clues, and my grumpy Persian cat, Tiger, I’m on a mission to uncover the truth.

But as I dig deeper into Rick’s shadowy past, I realize that Huckleberry Hollow might not be as cozy as it seems.

Perfect for fans of: Small-town intrigue, quirky characters, and a cozy mystery with a feline sidekick that adds his own brand of grumpy charm to the investigation.

Story Tropes:

  1. Crime element that is a puzzle
  2. Quirky side characters
  3. Multiple suspects
  4. Unsympathetic victim 
  5. Light humor
  6. Community Connections
  7. Sidekick Pet
  8. Red Herring 
  9. Murder
  10. Gossipy Best Friend
  11. Cop or other authority figure that discourages amateur sleuth 
SKU
MSSB-1-24
Vendor
Letters by Lanternlight
Product Type
Print Books
Tags
Cozy Mystery, huckleberry hollow, story

Customer Reviews

Based on 20 reviews
75%
(15)
10%
(2)
10%
(2)
0%
(0)
5%
(1)
K
Kelly
Enjoyable

I’ve just starting and it is okay. It’s simple.

Hi Kelly,

Thank you so much for starting Lydia's first mystery with us and for sharing your thoughts! We're so glad you're finding it enjoyable.

The simplicity you're noticing is intentional—we craft our mysteries to be accessible and inviting, a refreshing escape from everyday complexity. As the 24 letters progress, you'll discover layered clues, surprising connections, and character moments that reveal themselves in ways that make you smile when it all clicks into place.

We'd love for you to keep opening those letters and see where Lydia takes you. Sometimes the best mysteries are the ones that sneak up on you! ️

Thank you again for being part of the Lanternlight community!

Warmly,
Dawn

D
DM
Best Gift!!!

I bought this for my mom and she loves it. She's always been an avid mystery lover and this is just perfect! She said she can hardly wait for the next letter to arrive. Worth every penny in my opinion. PS: I LOVE the cat Tiger!

Hi DM! ️

This absolutely made my day! There's nothing that brings me more joy than hearing that a gift has brought so much happiness between you and your mom.

Your mom sounds like my kind of person—an avid mystery lover with great taste! I'm thrilled she's eagerly awaiting each letter. That anticipation for the mail is exactly the magic we're trying to create.

And I LOVE that you love Tiger! That grumpy Persian has stolen so many hearts (even though he'd never admit he enjoys the attention).
Thank you for trusting Letters by Lanternlight with such a meaningful gift. We're lucky to have readers like both of you in our community.

Warmly,
Dawn

K
Karen Clark
I bought as a gift for my mom

I bought as a gift for my mom. She is loving it.

Hi Karen,
Thank you so much for this wonderful review! ️ It warms my heart to hear that your mom is loving Murder at Sugar & Spice Bakery. There's nothing better than knowing our cozy mysteries are bringing joy to families!
Thank you for choosing us as a gift - it means the world to me. Please give your mom my warmest regards from Huckleberry Hollow!

Happy sleuthing! ✨
Dawn

A
Anonymous
I think I need more time to get into it

I think I need more time to get into it. I haven't received enough clues to get a sense of who the main characters are and what the story actually is about yet.

Thank you for your honest feedback, Susan. The early letters are just the beginning, and there’s much more to discover as the story unfolds over the next 20 letters for you! I hope the next clues bring the characters and mystery to life for you. Please let me know if you ever have questions or want hints—I’m here to help. - Best, Dawn

L
LESA
A great gift.

I ordered this for my mom in law for her 91st birthday. The 1st letter did not arrive so I contacted the company and was immediately replied to and they resent the letter. She was so excited to get these letters. she loves it, and plans on making the recipes. I highly recommend this as a gift for someone who has everything. The product and the costumer service is awesome.

Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re thrilled your mom-in-law is enjoying “Murder at Sugar and Spice Bakery”—and we loved making sure her letters arrived. If she bakes any of the recipes, please let us know! We’re so grateful for your recommendation and support. ✨