Mistletoe & Mayhem: A Huckleberry Hollow 6-Letter Mini-Mystery All-In-One Box
Mistletoe & Mayhem: A Huckleberry Hollow 6-Letter Mini-Mystery All-In-One Box
Couldn't load pickup availability
Free Shipping
30 Day Money Back Guarantee
Family Friendly
How It Works
How It Works
When you join Letters by Lanternlight, if you order an all-in-box you'll receive all the letters at once, and if you order the twice-monthly mystery experience, you’ll receive a new letter in the mail twice a month for 12 months.
These letters bring to life an immersive tale told through the diary of our protagonist, Lydia Bellweather, as she uncovers secrets in the charming town of Huckleberry Hollow and abroad. Alongside each letter, you’ll find immersive clues and keepsakes that make the experience tactile and interactive, inviting you to enter the mystery and experience the secrets alongside her.
Through every carefully written word and thoughtfully designed detail, our goal is to rekindle the joy of connection, screen-free—both to the story and to a community of fellow readers who share in the adventure.
What will you discover in your cozy mystery experience?
Reviews
I can't get enough of that tiger. He is something else. So just for starters. I just wanna say this was my first series that I read by this small business. My initial impression was it was well crafted. The illustrations are absolutely beautiful. I loved reading the newspapers that are included. What a beautiful touch. Lots of attention to detail here.
I have ordered three of the series by this author, and I've ordered the rest of them as well. Just have not read them all. She's doing a great job. One other thing that I'd like to say. I subscribe to a lot of Mail subscription services that send those letters once a month. In my opinion, this one's the best one. It has the best details. It has the best inserts. The diary entries are beautiful to look at the print is big and clearer. However, the inserts. The postcards with tiger's observations and the maps and everything else that you get. It's differs with each letter. However, I was super excited to see what the next one will bring. Highly recommend. Great job and I thoroughly enjoyed it.
It was a birthday gift for a friend. She loved it!
As usual this story was great! Tiger on a train...a new experience for him!! Keep the stories coming!
honestly didn’t expect to fall in love with this experience as much as I did. ✨
From the moment I opened the envelope, it felt magical, cozy, and incredibly immersive. The storytelling, the details, and the atmosphere made it feel like I had stepped into another world for a little while.
In a time where everything feels rushed and digital, receiving something this thoughtful and beautifully crafted felt so special. I couldn’t stop reading and already can’t wait for the next letter 🤍📬
I loved the Woman Who Didn't Exist! The surprise was excellent. I am thoroughly enjoying that each mini-mystery gets better and better. I can't wait for the next one.
FAQ
FAQ
What are Letters by Lanternlight?
Letters by Lanternlight is a company created by author Dawn Porter that includes snail-mail stories that unfold in a series of letters mailed to you at a rate of 2 letters per month. Stories range from 3 months to 12 months in duration so that you can pick a length that is right for you. Our stories are cozy mystery and PG-rated. There is no on-page violence, romance, or foul language. There is a posted mailing schedule, but in general, letters are mailed on the second and fourth Wednesday of each month (some exceptions due to holidays, etc.). We also offer an all-in-one box where you can have an entire story mailed to you at once to read at your pace. Our letters are easy to read with large font, no hard to decipher script and large 9.5x6 envelopes. They are easy on the eyes.
How can I reach customer service?
You can reach us via e-mail at hello@lanternlightletters.com, via chat at www.lanternlightletters.com, and via snail mail PO Box 900862, Sandy, UT 84090
What do I receive with my story?
Stories range in length from 6 to 24 letters. 24-letter stories are mailed 2 letters per month. Each 6x9.5 envelope contains a letter in the form of a diary entry or letter to another character plus 2-6 interactive elements ranging from recipe cards, newspaper clippings, maps, brochures, etc. We also offer all-in-one boxes for the 24-letter stories if you prefer to receive your story all at once. All 6-letter stories are all-in-one story boxes.
What is the difference between monthly plan and annual pre-paid story and the all-in-one story box?
Annual pre-paid stories are the most cost effective as they give you the lowest price per letter. You will receive 2 letters per month until your story is complete.
If you opt for a monthly payment plan, your billing method will be charged the first of each month at $14.99 per month which will entitle you to two letters per month until the story is completed.
If you prefer to receive your story all at once, you can purchase an all-in-one box. Each envelope will be addressed to "Lanternlight Friend" and sealed with the entire series of envelopes contained in a thoughtfully designed mailer box.
Does my monthly plan automatically renew at the end of my story?
Monthly plans will automatically renew through the entirety of your selected story. Once a story is complete, there is not an auto-renew. You will need to purchase another story either by all-in-once story box, annual pre-paid or monthly payment plan.
Do we have to receive these in order? Are there spoilers?
While each story is a standalone, there may be town characters that are suspects in one story and then show up in another story, meaning they were cleared from having committed the crime. The order of publication of the stories is posted below:
1. Murder at Sugar & Spice Bakery (February 2025) - Huckleberry Hollow
2. The Portrait of Deception (April 2025) - Huckleberry Hollow
3. The Vanishing Compass (October 2025) - Sand Dollar Sound
4. Mistletoe & Mayhem (November 2025) - Huckleberry Hollow
5. The Woman Who Didn't Exist (April 2026) - The Evergreen Express
Are these stories appropriate for children?
Our stories are cozy mystery and PG-rated. There is no on-page violence, romance, or foul language. Having said that, interest in the topics (land deals gone wrong, missing family heirlooms, off-page murders, etc.) is best suited for 16 and up.
Order
How do I order for myself?
Visit www.lettersbylanternlight.com and select the story you wish to receive.
Enter your own shipping address.
Enter your billing information.
Submit your order and look for the confirmation e-mail. Your first letter will be mailed according to the posted mailing dates.
If you are ordering merchandise, add the item to your cart and check out as you would for the story above. Shipping options will present themselves upon checkout.
How do I order as a gift?
There are two ways to order as a gift.
Simply Purchase the Story: When you purchase the story, simply enter the recipient's shipping address (we recommend that you use your own address as the billing address).
Monetary Gift Card: you may purchase a gift card at any monetary value and send to a recipient. They can use the gift card to place an order for their own story or merchandise. Please note that when they place their order, they will be charged sales tax for the state where they will have their story shipped. You may wish to increase the value of your gift card to cover the sales tax.
In either case, you can print and mail, or download and e-mail a Gift Just for You! Notice to get your recipient excited about their special gift.
When will I receive my letters?
Please refer to the Mailing Dates calendar to see when an order must be placed in order to receive a letter by a specific mailing date. If this is a gift, plan your purchase around the mailing dates.
Please allow 2 weeks from mailing in the USA and 4-6 weeks for international mailings.
When will I receive my non-letter merchandise?
Once an order for merchandise other than stories is received, we mail your products within 3-5 business days. You will receive a confirmation e-mail of your order. You will also receive a shipping notice for your order.
My letter or product never arrived. What do I do?
We use USPS for mailing letters and products. Please allow 2 weeks from shipping date (refer to Mailing Dates for letters) within the US and 4-6 weeks for international delivery.
If you have not received your product by those dates we will resend at no charge to you due to damage or loss because of Letters by Lanternlight or USPS.
If a letter is lost or returned to us due to an inaccurate address provided, these letters can be resent at a surcharge of $7 US or $9 international.
We rely on timely information provided by our guests to ensure the correct mailing addresses so that letters are deliverable to the intended person. Please provide an accurate and deliverable address when checking out, and promptly update your mailing address with us if it changes during the mailing period by sending an e-mail to hello@lanternlightletters.com.
Notifying the post office changes your mailing address with the post office but not with us. After a period of time, they will not forward your mail. If letters are missing due to not notifying us in a timely manner, we can resend one letter at no cost.
If you need help with a missing letter or product, please e-mail us at hello@lanternlightletters.com with the following information:
Order # or e-mail address that you ordered from
Recipient Name
Story name and letter number that is missing or product name that is missing
Address to send the replacement letter
Please allow us up to 5 business days to look into the matter with USPS and respond.
Shipping
Where do you ship?
We ship via USPS and ship anywhere the USPS ships. Shipping within the United States is included in story orders. Additional shipping will be calculated at check-out for international story orders and any merchandise US and/or international.
What if I move? How do I change my address?
Please promptly update your mailing address with us if it changes during the mailing period by sending an e-mail to hello@lanternlightletters.com.
Notifying the post office changes your mailing address with the post office but not with us. After a period of time, they will not forward your mail. If letters are missing due to not notifying us in a timely manner, we can resend one letter at no cost.
Do you send orders internationally?
We ship via USPS and ship anywhere the USPS ships. International shipping will be calculated at check-out for mystery letters and any merchandise.
How do I return an order and receive a refund?
Please note our Refund Policy and reach out to hello@lanternlightletters.com with any questions.
Products
What Products do you currently carry?
Murder at Sugar & Spice Bakery: A Small Town Cozy Mystery by Mail
The Portrait of Deception: A Small-Town Cozy Mini-Mystery
The Vanishing Compass: A Small-Town 24-Letter Cozy Mystery
Mistletoe & Mayhem: A Huckleberry Hollow 6-Letter Mini-Mystery All-In-One Box
The Woman Who Didn't Exist: A Huckleberry Hollow 6-Letter Train Mini-Mystery All-In-One Box
Ultimate Gift Bundles
2 Tiger the sidekick coffee mugs – 16oz.
Gift Cards
Returns & Refunds
What is the return/refund policy?
Our Guarantee
Our guest’s satisfaction is our top priority. If you are dissatisfied, please notify us immediately so we can help you.
Under certain circumstances, we may issue refunds. If you’ve been approved for a refund by Letters by Lanternlight, the approved amount will be returned to the original payment method within 7 - 10 business days via Shopify.
See our Return and refund policies here
Billing & Payments
What if I need to change my payment information or billing address?
If you have a prepaid annual story purchase, your order was successfully processed, and no updates are needed, nor are they possible, as Shopify does not store your information. For any new order, you can enter your correct billing information.
If you have a monthly plan, you can cancel or update your billing information by clicking Manage My Plan. You must use the e-mail address that you ordered from. If you have any issues, please reach out to us at hello@lanternlightletters.com with your e-mail address or order number, recipient name, and story you are receiving.
Cozy Mystery Collection
-
The Vanishing Compass: A Small-Town 24-Letter Cozy Mystery
Regular price From $14.99 USDRegular priceUnit price per$189.99 USDSale price From $14.99 USDSale
I can't get enough of that tiger. He is something else. So just for starters. I just wanna say this was my first series that I read by this small business. My initial impression was it was well crafted. The illustrations are absolutely beautiful. I loved reading the newspapers that are included. What a beautiful touch. Lots of attention to detail here.
I have ordered three of the series by this author, and I've ordered the rest of them as well. Just have not read them all. She's doing a great job. One other thing that I'd like to say. I subscribe to a lot of Mail subscription services that send those letters once a month. In my opinion, this one's the best one. It has the best details. It has the best inserts. The diary entries are beautiful to look at the print is big and clearer. However, the inserts. The postcards with tiger's observations and the maps and everything else that you get. It's differs with each letter. However, I was super excited to see what the next one will bring. Highly recommend. Great job and I thoroughly enjoyed it.
My son gave me this as a Christmas Gift because he knows how much I enjoy reading cozy mysteries. I have just opened the first letter and I am already "hooked". This is a great idea, and I can see that I will have a great adventure ahead. I am only allowing myself to open one letter per day so I can make the adventure last longer!
Oh Diane… thank you for taking the time to share this. Please tell your son he absolutely nailed the Christmas gift! I’m thrilled you’re already hooked, and I love your one-letter-a-day plan—there’s something so magical about letting the mystery unfold slowly. Cozy wishes for a delightful adventure ahead! Warmly, Dawn
What a gorgeous way to enjoy a mystery. This kit is truly a work of art. Or perhaps I should say it is a collection of beautiful works of art. I was able to see pictures of all the major characters, unlike in reading a mystery book where I have to try to imagine who they are and see them in my minds eye. Each document is similarly creative. For example, the final solution is presented as a page from a newspaper. I would like to treat myself to another of these mysteries and also send one as a gift to a friend who likes mysteries as much as I do.
M. Anderson, thank you so much for this beautiful review — I’m truly honored. I love that you enjoyed seeing the characters and stepping into the story through all the creative documents (and yes — that newspaper-style final solution is one of my favorite touches).
Thank you for noticing the artistry in each piece. If you decide to treat yourself to another mystery (or send one as a gift), I hope it brings the same cozy, can’t-wait-to-open-the-next-envelope feeling. Warmly, Dawn
She totally loves it!
I am now the best giftgiiver in her world.
Frequent enough to keep her interested without intruding on her time. Short even timeline to keep her end of year schedules on track.
Thank you so much for sharing this! We love hearing that The Portrait of Deception made the perfect gift for your BFF. It means the world to know she’s enjoying the mystery without the time crunch. You just made our day (and hers)! ️
It was a birthday gift for a friend. She loved it!
As usual this story was great! Tiger on a train...a new experience for him!! Keep the stories coming!
honestly didn’t expect to fall in love with this experience as much as I did. ✨
From the moment I opened the envelope, it felt magical, cozy, and incredibly immersive. The storytelling, the details, and the atmosphere made it feel like I had stepped into another world for a little while.
In a time where everything feels rushed and digital, receiving something this thoughtful and beautifully crafted felt so special. I couldn’t stop reading and already can’t wait for the next letter 🤍📬
I loved the Woman Who Didn't Exist! The surprise was excellent. I am thoroughly enjoying that each mini-mystery gets better and better. I can't wait for the next one.
I loved the format and lightness. A great escape in an easy read— just delightful!
I loved it and I got the whole pack all at once and I buzzed through them just so I could figure out the ending. They were great
I loved it. It kept me going until the very last letter. It was wonderful
Well written diary and clues
Loved it, so much fun!
Thank you so much, Joanna! I’m thrilled to hear you loved Mistletoe & Mayhem and had fun with the adventure. Bringing a little extra joy and mystery to your mailbox is what it’s all about! Wishing you many more cozy stories and fun surprises ahead! ✉️️
Warm wishes,
Dawn
My wife absolutely loved this. I bought it for her Christmas gift. She loved the mystery and story, but overall she loved the cat and his reports.
Jonas, thank you so much for sharing this! I’m thrilled your wife enjoyed her Christmas mystery—and especially Tiger’s reports. He always manages to steal the show! Wishing you both many more cozy adventures ahead. Warmly, Dawn
Bought as a gift. Quick shipping. Excellent packaging. My MOM loved it!
Glinda, this means the world to me—thank you for choosing Letters by Lanternlight for your mom! Thrilled she loved it, and I hope every letter brings a little extra joy and adventure her way. Warmly, Dawn
The letters and contents were beautifully crafted. The only reason for one less star is that I feel the actual mystery was a bit lacking as far as really building it up and deducing 'who done it' through the clues. It is a bit pricey when you compare it to purchasing a mystery book to read, so that is why I started with the more affordable mini-mystery. I like the protagonist, the story was enjoyable and I really liked the humor peppered throughout. The recipe cards were also a nice addition. I anticipate that I will try one of the 24 letter mystery boxes in the future when my budget allows. The delivery box, contents and ornament included were top notch. Love the cat.
Thank you so much, Dreaming of Beaches — I really appreciate such a thoughtful review. I’m so glad you enjoyed the humor, the recipe cards, the packaging (and yes… Tiger is pretty hard not to love!).
And thank you for the honest note about wanting more build-up and deduction through the clues — that’s incredibly helpful feedback. If you do decide to try one of the 24-letter story boxes in the future, I think you’ll really enjoy the longer runway for clue-spotting and ‘armchair detective’ moments. Warmly, Dawn
Family member this was purchased for is really excited about it. Everything packaged in a nice box.
I bought 2 of this story for Christmas gifts. I liked the packaging and the idea. The receiver of the stories are excited but have not read the stories yet. I am excited to see how they liked it.
Denise, thank you so much for gifting Mistletoe & Mayhem — I’m really glad the packaging and the concept felt special right from the start.
Since they haven’t had a chance to read it yet, I’d love to hear what they think once they begin (and what you hear back!). If anything about the gifting experience could be even smoother or more magical next time, I’m always listening. With warmth, Dawn
Nancy love them. As with everything I've gotten from you she has been very pleased. And if she's happy I'm happy. After 48 years of marriage it is difficult to find things for each other that we haven't already bought. This is so different and new, and very good, that it's like a gift. Thank you for these wonderful choices and a well thought out and enjoyable product. And for making my gift giving a lot easier!
Bill, thank you so much — this is incredibly kind. Please tell Nancy I’m thrilled she’s loving the letters.
And truly… after 48 years of marriage, the fact that this felt different and new (and made gift-giving easier) means a lot to me. Thank you for trusting me with a gift for someone you love — I’m honored to be a small part of your story. Warmly, Dawn
This was a great mini mystery. It kept me engaged through all the letters and the ending was a real surprise. I have so much fun. This is a great idea! Keep them coming!!
Thank you so much, Linda — this made my day. I’m thrilled you had fun with the mini mystery and stayed hooked all the way through (and I love that the ending surprised you!).
I’ll absolutely keep them coming — Lydia is already back at her desk chasing the next set of clues after the new year. With warmth, Dawn ️
Perfect Holiday Mystery! I loved this mini-mystery. It was entertaining and a lot of fun. It also revealed more of the Huckleberry Hollow town lore. I can't wait to dive into more stories with Lydia and the town of Huckleberry Hollow.
Rachel, thank you so much for this beautiful review! ️ We're thrilled the holiday mystery brought you joy and that you're discovering more of Huckleberry Hollow's magic. Lydia and the town have so much more to reveal—we can't wait to welcome you back for the next adventure. With warmth and lanternlight, Dawn
I am 2 letters in now and I absolutely am hooked. I am so looking forward to the next letter!!! I think I have a lead but my sloth skins are not the best. Can't wait to find out who did it!!!!
Leslie, your excitement just made my day! ️ I’m so glad you’re enjoying The Portrait of Deception—your detective instincts are exactly what Lydia Bellweather loves in a fellow sleuth. The next letter is on its way, and I can’t wait for you to see what clues unfold. Thank you for sharing your journey with us! ✉️✨ I appreciate you! Warmly, Dawn Porter
These look so cute - I'm so excited for the mystery :D
So much fun! I plan to read it again. Thank you for a fun story escape.
Best, Alice
Dear Alice,
Your review absolutely made my day! Knowing The Portrait of Deception gave you that perfect story escape - and that you want to read it again - is the highest compliment I could receive!
Thank you for sharing your experience. Reviews like yours remind me exactly why I love creating these handwritten adventures. Here's to many more cozy mystery escapes by lanternlight! ️
With gratitude,
Dawn
I loved this small town mini-mystery. I'm already invested in the characters since I receive Murder at The Sugar and Spice Bakery so I loved watching Lydia crack another case. Tiger is a delight as always. It's amazing how all the pieces come together.
Hi Rachel,
Thank you for this amazing review! ️ I'm so thrilled you loved The Portrait of Deception and that you're already so invested in Lydia's world. It makes my heart happy to know Tiger continues to delight you - he does have quite the snarky personality.
Your observation about how all the pieces come together means everything to me as the storyteller. Thank you for being such a loyal cozy mystery lover and for sharing your experience!
Happy sleuthing! ✨
Dawn
A Unique Experience—To Keep Or To Gift
✨Why Readers Love Letters by Lanternlight📚Fresh & immersive– A mystery you can hold in your hands, one letter at a time.
🎁A gift that stands out– Thoughtful, unique, and never “just more stuff.”
🔎Simple & inviting– Large, easy-to-read font and straightforward storytelling—no codes or puzzles required.
🕵️Screen-free escape– Cozy stories delivered straight to your mailbox.
🐾Connection & delight– Fun to share with loved ones (or enjoy with tea and a cat).
⏳Savor the suspense– Stories unfold slowly, with built-in anticipation.
"I purchased for my Mother and she absolutely loves it. She is only two letters in and excited for the next."- Robert Bell
Letters By Lanternlight Mailing Dates
About The Author
Thank you so much for stopping by and for supporting a small family business. I live with my family and our animal tribe of dogs and a horse in Sandy, Utah, where stories and everyday life often blend together.
After more than 20 years as a grant writer, I started Letters by Lanternlight to bring back the joy of non-digital, tactile storytelling—a cozy way to reconnect with ourselves and each other. Every character (furry or otherwise) and town is inspired by my real life experiences.
Speaking of connecting, customer care and satisfaction is close to my heart—when you write in, there’s a good chance you’re hearing back from me personally.
With warmth and mystery,
Dawn Porter