Cozy Mystery Collection
Each story stands alone with a satisfying happily-ever-after—no cliffhangers, no loose ends. Read in any order, or start with our first story, Murder at Sugar & Spice Bakery to catch all the town gossip.
Immersive Cozy Mystery Stories, One Letter at a Time
Choose a full 24-letter mystery delivered by mail or in one complete box, or begin with a shorter 6-letter mini mystery.
Shop 24-letter StoriesShop 6-letter StoriesShop Gifts and KeepsakesStep into a world of handwritten cozy mysteries, where every letter brings a new twist, a heartfelt moment, and the joy of connection.
No screens. No stress. Just the joy of storytelling the old-fashioned way.
How It Works
Choose Your Serial Cozy Mystery
Each letter is a chapter in the story, mailed twice per month
(story boxes ship all letters at once, if you don't want to wait!)
Follow Along, Letter by letter
Each letter has large, easy-to-read font and comes with companion clues and delightful keepsakes to bring the mystery to life.
Enjoy the charm of your Cozy Mystery: Who Is it for?
Book club? Grandparents? Yourself with a cozy cup of tea? These mysteries spark delight for all.
Mission Statement
At Letters by Lanternlight, we believe in the simple yet profound joy of connection. Through heartfelt stories delivered by mail, we bring people together to share in the warmth of belonging and the thrill of uncovering a mystery. Each letter is an invitation to pause, reflect, and immerse yourself in a hands-on journey of friendship, discovery, and shared wonder. Whether you're a lifelong reader or a curious sleuth, you're part of a community that values the beauty of storytelling and the magic of human connection. Together, we illuminate the path to stories that feel like home.
Vision Statement
Our vision is to build a world where stories bridge distances and bring people closer, fostering a sense of belonging one letter at a time. We aspire to create a community that values shared moments, heartfelt connections, and the timeless magic of storytelling. By rekindling the charm of snail mail and weaving mysteries that spark curiosity, we envision a future where every person feels a part of something meaningful, united by the power of connection and the stories that illuminate our lives.
Let customers speak for us
Our detective!!
May I say my favorite part of getting my letters is to see the gorgeous face of our lovely detective!! He is perfect. Thank you for all this great stories. I had to cancel all the other letters BUT had to keep your!!! Thank you
Margaret Barry
Soo cute!
I really enjoyed this cozy mystery.The little extras that came with the letters and in the box made it more special than just reading a book. I'm definitely ordering another box.
Angela Givens
I absolutely loved this!!! Gonna buy another All-in-One Box now!!!
Kristi
Lovely box to hold All my stories!
Paula
Everything is absolutely wonderful. I have bought 2 mini mysteries and waiting for Thanksgiving to get the Christmas one, ordered the Vanishing Compass and going to order the other 12 month one for myself for Christmas. That’s it. I’ll have all of them. So what’s a girl to do? BEG FOR MORE. Please keep writing. I need you. Hahahaha.
Paula
FireFly Explorers box being a hit
Hello, the explorers box was a hit with the neighbor boy before he and his family moved. The box arrived right in time and just before they left to move to Nome Alaska.
Michelle A Frank
Praises for having interesting mysteries for all ages!!!!!
Shopping Letters By Lanterlight is very simple and the Firefly Mystery for children is amazing. Mysteries for all ages.
Sharon Ashbridge
Firefly member involvement
Love to see how the Firefly members get involved and to see how they interpret each clue.
Anonymous
I love her products:) This gave my friend lots of joy. She is currently reading about the Compass and exploring with Lydia and Tiger. She is loving it as much as I did. 🤗🤗🤗
Lisa
Protection Assurance is Good!
It's good to know that if anything happens, 'insurance' covers it and I can get a replacement...
VeronicaLynn
Sent it to my best friend and she loved it!! Said it was one of the best gifts she’s ever received
Sent it to my best friend and she loved it!! Said it was one of the best gifts she’s ever received.
Anonymous
This story is perfect for kids! Engaging and filled with activities
This story is perfect for kids! Engaging and filled with activities. I loved it even as an adult.
Rachel Corsini
I loved the mystery it has kept me engaged in reading it to the very end
I loved the mystery it has kept me engaged in reading it to the very end. I love the ending it was one I never saw coming. It was a great read
Michelle A Frank
I am having fun with the mystery
I am having fun with the mystery. Your product is so much more than I expected. Waiting on the letters is part of the fun!
Nicolette W Creel
Loving letters
Loving them so far really enjoying reading them to follow along
Anonymous
A Unique Experience—To Keep or to Gift
✨ Why Readers Love Letters by Lanternlight
📚 Fresh & immersive – A mystery you can hold in your hands, one letter at a time.
🎁 A gift that stands out – Thoughtful, unique, and never “just more stuff.”
🔎 Simple & inviting – Large, easy-to-read font and straightforward storytelling—no codes or puzzles required.
🕵️ Screen-free escape – Cozy stories delivered straight to your mailbox.
🐾 Connection & delight – Fun to share with loved ones (or enjoy with tea and a cat).
⏳ Savor the suspense – Stories unfold slowly, with built-in anticipation.
"I purchased for my Mother and she absolutely loves it. She is only two letters in and excited for the next." - Robert Bell
About the Author
Thank you so much for stopping by and for supporting a small family business. I live with my family and our animal tribe of dogs and a horse in Sandy, Utah, where stories and everyday life often blend together.
After more than 20 years as a grant writer, I started Letters by Lanternlight to bring back the joy of non-digital, tactile storytelling—a cozy way to reconnect with ourselves and each other. Every character (furry or otherwise) and town is inspired by my real life experiences.
Speaking of connecting, customer care and satisfaction is close to my heart—when you write in, there’s a good chance you’re hearing back from me personally.
With warmth and mystery,
Dawn Porter
How It Works
When you join Letters by Lanternlight, you’ll receive a new letter in the mail twice a month.
These letters bring to life an immersive tale told through the diary of our protagonist, Lydia Bellweather, as she uncovers secrets in the charming town of Huckleberry Hollow and abroad. Alongside each letter, you’ll find immersive clues and keepsakes that make the experience tactile and interactive, inviting you to enter the mystery and experience the secrets alongside her.
Through every carefully written word and thoughtfully designed detail, our goal is to rekindle the joy of connection, screen-free—both to the story and to a community of fellow readers who share in the adventure.
Question? Chat With Us!
Click the Chat in the bottom right & we'll respond as soon as we can!
QUALITY ASSURANCE
We deliver the best products
PAYMENT METHODS
All Major Credit Cards, Venmo, Shop, PayPal, Google Pay, and Apple Pay accepted
Let customers speak for us
Our detective!!
May I say my favorite part of getting my letters is to see the gorgeous face of our lovely detective!! He is perfect. Thank you for all this great stories. I had to cancel all the other letters BUT had to keep your!!! Thank you
Margaret Barry
Soo cute!
I really enjoyed this cozy mystery.The little extras that came with the letters and in the box made it more special than just reading a book. I'm definitely ordering another box.
Angela Givens
I absolutely loved this!!! Gonna buy another All-in-One Box now!!!
Kristi
Lovely box to hold All my stories!
Paula
Everything is absolutely wonderful. I have bought 2 mini mysteries and waiting for Thanksgiving to get the Christmas one, ordered the Vanishing Compass and going to order the other 12 month one for myself for Christmas. That’s it. I’ll have all of them. So what’s a girl to do? BEG FOR MORE. Please keep writing. I need you. Hahahaha.
Paula
FireFly Explorers box being a hit
Hello, the explorers box was a hit with the neighbor boy before he and his family moved. The box arrived right in time and just before they left to move to Nome Alaska.
Michelle A Frank
Praises for having interesting mysteries for all ages!!!!!
Shopping Letters By Lanterlight is very simple and the Firefly Mystery for children is amazing. Mysteries for all ages.
Sharon Ashbridge
Firefly member involvement
Love to see how the Firefly members get involved and to see how they interpret each clue.
Anonymous
I love her products:) This gave my friend lots of joy. She is currently reading about the Compass and exploring with Lydia and Tiger. She is loving it as much as I did. 🤗🤗🤗
Lisa
Protection Assurance is Good!
It's good to know that if anything happens, 'insurance' covers it and I can get a replacement...
VeronicaLynn
Sent it to my best friend and she loved it!! Said it was one of the best gifts she’s ever received
Sent it to my best friend and she loved it!! Said it was one of the best gifts she’s ever received.
Anonymous
This story is perfect for kids! Engaging and filled with activities
This story is perfect for kids! Engaging and filled with activities. I loved it even as an adult.
Rachel Corsini
I loved the mystery it has kept me engaged in reading it to the very end
I loved the mystery it has kept me engaged in reading it to the very end. I love the ending it was one I never saw coming. It was a great read
Michelle A Frank
I am having fun with the mystery
I am having fun with the mystery. Your product is so much more than I expected. Waiting on the letters is part of the fun!
Nicolette W Creel
Loving letters
Loving them so far really enjoying reading them to follow along
Anonymous
OUR CUSTOMERS SAY
Mildred Mason
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. In vitae venenatis nisi, at pellentesque turpis. Mauris ipsum augue, sodales vitae nibh eget, congue ornare augue. Donec sollicitudin mauris eu dui lobortis condimentum. Aenean luctus mattis feugiat. Pellentesque ultrices nunc vel nunc placerat ultricies.
Randy Tyler
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. In vitae venenatis nisi, at pellentesque turpis. Mauris ipsum augue, sodales vitae nibh eget, congue ornare augue. Donec sollicitudin mauris eu dui lobortis condimentum. Aenean luctus mattis feugiat. Pellentesque ultrices nunc vel nunc placerat ultricies.
Edwin MCKenzie
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. In vitae venenatis nisi, at pellentesque turpis. Mauris ipsum augue, sodales vitae nibh eget, congue ornare augue. Donec sollicitudin mauris eu dui lobortis condimentum. Aenean luctus mattis feugiat. Pellentesque ultrices nunc vel nunc placerat ultricies.
Letters by Lanternlight Mailing Dates
Your first letter will be mailed within 3 business days. Your second letter will mail with the next closest mailing date. Click the "View More" button to see the mailing dates for the year.
Mailings arrive at the United States Postal Service (USPS) on the 2nd and 4th Wednesday of the month. Letters will be delivered within 2 weeks for orders within the United States and 6 weeks for international orders.
All-in-one story boxes and other merchandise will be mailed within 3-5 business days. You will receive a shipping notification with tracking information.